| July 14, 1961 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | Supermodified | Rollie Beale | |
| July 16, 1961 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | Supermodified | Dick Carter | |
| July 21, 1961 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | Supermodified | Rollie Beale | |
| July 30, 1961 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | Supermodified | Gordon Dukes | |
| August 4, 1961 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | Supermodified | Rollie Beale | |
| August 6, 1961 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | Supermodified | Gordon Dukes | |
| August 11, 1961 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | Supermodified | Dick Carter | |
| August 13, 1961 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | Supermodified | Rollie Beale | |
| August 13, 1961 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | Supermodified | Gordon Dukes | |
| August 18, 1961 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | Modified | Dick Carter | |
| May 6, 1962 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Stock Car | Dick Freeman | |
| August 4, 1962 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Stock Car | Paul Parks | |
| April 21, 1963 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Stock Car | Iggy Katona | |
| May 3, 1964 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Stock Car | Jim Cushman | |
| May 23, 1965 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Stock Car | Jack Bowsher | |
| July 5, 1965 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Stock Car | Jack Bowsher | |
| May 1, 1966 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Stock Car | Iggy Katona | |
| July 4, 1966 | Kenny Nemire Memorial | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Stock Car | Les Snow |
| September 5, 1966 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Stock Car | Les Snow | |
| April 30, 1967 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Stock Car | Iggy Katona | |
| September 4, 1967 | 2nd Kenny Nemire Night | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Stock Car | Andy Hampton |
| May 5, 1968 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Stock Car | Benny Parsons | |
| July 20, 1968 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Stock Car | Benny Parsons | |
| June 21, 1969 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | USAC Sprint Car | Bruce Walkup | |
| August 2, 1969 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Stock Car | Benny Parsons | |
| April 26, 1970 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Stock Car | Bobby Watson | |
| June 27, 1970 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | USAC Sprint Car | Gary Bettenhausen | |
| September 7, 1970 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Stock Car | Tom Bowsher | |
| April 25, 1971 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Stock Car | Tom Bowsher | |
| June 26, 1971 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | USAC Sprint Car | Rollie Beale | |
| July 4, 1971 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Stock Car | Tom Bowsher | |
| September 5, 1971 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Stock Car | Ramo Stott | |
| July 2, 1972 | Toledo 100 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Stock Car | Ron Hutcherson |
| August 18, 1972 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Stock Car | Joy Fair | |
| May 6, 1973 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Stock Car | Bruce Gould | |
| July 1, 1973 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Stock Car | Bruce Gould | |
| July 28, 1973 | Toledo 100 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | NASCAR/ARCA Grand National East | Bruce Gould |
| September 1, 1974 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Stock Car | Bruce Gould | |
| June 28, 1975 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Stock Car | Dave Dayton John Anderson | |
| August 31, 1975 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Stock Car | Woody Fisher | |
| June 27, 1976 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Stock Car | Dave Dayton | |
| August 29, 1976 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Stock Car | Dave Dayton | |
| October 10, 1976 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Stock Car | Larry LaMay | |
| June 26, 1977 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Stock Car | Moose Myers | |
| September 11, 1977 | 4th Howard Williams Memorial 300 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Stock Car | Moose Myers |
| May 20, 1979 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ASA Stock Car | Rich Knotts | |
| May 30, 1981 | Toledo 200 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ASA Stock Car | Mike Eddy |
| August 14, 1982 | Amsoil 200 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ASA Stock Car | Joe Ruttman |
| June 4, 1983 | Silver Creek 300 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ASA Stock Car | Rusty Wallace |
| September 15, 1984 | Silver Dollar 150 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Stock Car | Howard Rose |
| September 15, 1985 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Stock Car | Ed Hage | |
| September 7, 1986 | Toledo 150 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Stock Car | Scott Stovall |
| May 31, 1987 | Toledo 125 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Stock Car | Bill Venturini |
| August 27, 1989 | Snap-On Tools 125 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Stock Car | Bob Strait |
| July 1, 1990 | Toledo ARCA 125 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Stock Car | Bob Strait |
| August 26, 1990 | Snap-On Tools ARCA 125 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Stock Car | Bob Keselowski |
| May 26, 1991 | Toledo 125 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Stock Car | Bobby Bowsher |
| August 25, 1991 | Snap-On Tools 125 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Stock Car | Bobby Bowsher |
| October 20, 1991 | Toledo 400 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ASA Stock Car | Scott Hansen |
| May 24, 1992 | Toledo 125 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Stock Car | Bob Strait |
| August 30, 1992 | Pedigree Food for Dogs 125 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Stock Car | Bobby Bowsher |
| October 3, 1992 | Glass City 100 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARTGO Stock Car | Butch Miller |
| October 4, 1992 | Toledo 400 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ASA Stock Car | Bob Senneker |
| May 30, 1993 | Toledo 125 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Stock Car | Bobby Bowsher |
| September 12, 1993 | Toledo 150 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Stock Car | Dave Weltmeyer |
| October 3, 1993 | Toledo 400 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ASA Stock Car | Johnny Benson Jr. |
| May 15, 1994 | Glass City 300 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ASA Stock Car | Butch Miller |
| May 22, 1994 | Toledo 150 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Stock Car | Frank Kimmel |
| September 11, 1994 | Winnebago 150 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Stock Car | Bobby Bowsher |
| October 2, 1994 | Toledo 400 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ASA Stock Car | Scott Hansen |
| May 7, 1995 | Glass City 300 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ASA Stock Car | Mike Eddy |
| October 1, 1995 | Toledo 400 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ASA Stock Car | Bryan Reffner |
| May 5, 1996 | Glass City 300 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ASA Stock Car | Scott Hansen |
| July 7, 1996 | Auto Value Parts Stores 150 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Stock Car | Frank Kimmel |
| September 29, 1996 | Toledo 400 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ASA Stock Car | Brad Loney |
| June 29, 1997 | Toledo 150 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Stock Car | Ken Schrader |
| June 28, 1998 | Toledo 150 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Stock Car | Frank Kimmel |
| June 25, 1999 | Jasper Engines & Transmissions 150 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Stock Car | Blaise Alexander |
| July 16, 1999 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Midget | A.J. Davis | |
| June 23, 2000 | Jasper Engines & Transmissions 150 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Stock Car | Frank Kimmel |
| July 30, 2000 | Glass City 300 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ASA Stock Car | Tim Sauter |
| June 8, 2001 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ISMA Supermodified | Lou Cicconi Jr. | |
| July 1, 2001 | Glass City 300 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ASA Stock Car | Johnny Sauter |
| September 16, 2001 | Jasper Engines & Transmissions 200 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Stock Car | Frank Kimmel |
| June 14, 2002 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ISMA Supermodified | Russ Wood | |
| June 23, 2002 | Jasper Engines & Transmissions 200 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Stock Car | Frank Kimmel |
| August 11, 2002 | Metro Toledo Ford Dealers 300 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ASA Stock Car | Joey Clanton |
| May 4, 2003 | GFS Marketplace 200 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Stock Car | Frank Kimmel |
| May 18, 2003 | Glass City 300 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ASA Stock Car | Butch Miller |
| June 13, 2003 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ISMA Supermodified | Russ Wood | |
| August 10, 2003 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | MSA Supermodified | A.J. Davis | |
| May 16, 2004 | Hickory Farms 200 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Stock Car | Ken Schrader |
| June 18, 2004 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ISMA Supermodified | Pat Abold | |
| September 3, 2004 | Hantz Group 200 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Stock Car | Frank Kimmel |
| May 22, 2005 | Hantz Group 200 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Stock Car | Ken Schrader |
| June 17, 2005 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ISMA Supermodified | Pat Abold | |
| June 24, 2005 | Signature Harley Davidson & Toledo Harley Davidson/Buell 50 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Lincoln Welders Truck | Brett Rowe |
| August 19, 2005 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | MSA Supermodified | Jon Henes | |
| September 2, 2005 | Hantz Group 200 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Stock Car | Frank Kimmel |
| May 21, 2006 | Hantz Group 200 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Stock Car | Ken Schrader |
| June 16, 2006 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ISMA Supermodified | Nick Fornoro Jr. | |
| July 7, 2006 | Signature and Toledo Harley-Davidson 50 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Lincoln Welders Truck | Paul Hahn |
| August 25, 2006 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | MSA Supermodified | Moe Lilje | |
| September 1, 2006 | Hantz Group 200 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Stock Car | Chuck Barnes |
| May 20, 2007 | Hantz Group 200 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Stock Car | Ken Butler III |
| June 15, 2007 | All American Coach 50 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ISMA Supermodified | Chris Perley |
| August 3, 2007 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | MSA Supermodified | Dave Shullick Jr. | |
| October 14, 2007 | Hantz Group 200 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Stock Car | Michael McDowell |
| May 18, 2008 | Hantz Group 200 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Stock Car | Matt Carter |
| July 18, 2008 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | MSA Supermodified | Tim Jedrzejek | |
| October 12, 2008 | Hantz Group 200 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Stock Car | Justin Allgaier |
| May 17, 2009 | Menards 200 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Stock Car | Parker Kligerman |
| June 12, 2009 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ISMA Supermodified | Russ Wood | |
| July 3, 2009 | Hemelgarn Racing Super Fitness Night | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | USAC Midget | Bobby Santos III |
| July 3, 2009 | Hemelgarn Racing Super Fitness Night | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | USAC Sprint Car | Bobby East |
| August 7, 2009 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | MSA Supermodified | Trent Stephens | |
| September 4, 2009 | Re/MAX 200 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Stock Car | Justin Lofton |
| May 23, 2010 | Menards 200 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Stock Car | Chris Buescher |
| June 11, 2010 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | AVSS Sprint Car | Jason Blonde | |
| June 11, 2010 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | MSA Supermodified | Tim Ice | |
| July 2, 2010 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | USAC Midget | Darren Hagen | |
| July 2, 2010 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | USAC Sprint Car | Henry Clarke | |
| September 12, 2010 | Northwest Ohio Ford Dealers 200 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Stock Car | Chris Buescher |
| October 16, 2010 | Rollie Beale 150 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | USAC Silver Crown | Jerry Coons Jr. |
| May 15, 2011 | Menards 200 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Stock Car | Ty Dillon |
| June 17, 2011 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | MSA Supermodified | Bobby Dawson | |
| July 1, 2011 | Jerry Nemire Appreciation Night | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | USAC Pavement Sprint Car | Bobby East |
| July 1, 2011 | Jerry Nemire Appreciation Night | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | USAC Midget | Darren Hagen |
| October 15, 2011 | Rollie Beale 150 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | USAC Silver Crown | Kody Swanson |
| October 15, 2011 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | USAC Mopar D1 Midget | Kyle Hamilton | |
| October 16, 2011 | Federated Car Care 200 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Stock Car | Chris Buescher |
| May 20, 2012 | Menards 200 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Stock Car | Chris Buescher |
| June 15, 2012 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | MSA Supermodified | Mike Lichty | |
| June 29, 2012 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | USAC Midget | Caleb Armstrong | |
| June 29, 2012 | Rollie Beale 100 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | USAC Silver Crown | Jerry Coons Jr. |
| April 20, 2013 | Border Wars 7-Up 150 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Midwest Tour/CRA Super Series | Johnny Van Doorn |
| May 19, 2013 | Menards 200 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Stock Car | Ken Schrader |
| June 14, 2013 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | MSA Supermodified | Jimmy McCune | |
| May 18, 2014 | Menards 200 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Stock Car | Justin Boston |
| June 13, 2014 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | AVSS Sprint Car | Ryan Litt | |
| June 13, 2014 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | MSA Supermodified | Trent Stephens | |
| July 2, 2014 | Rollie Beale Classic | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | AVSS Sprint Car | JoJo Helberg |
| May 1, 2015 | Rollie Beale Classic | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | USAC Silver Crown | Kody Swanson |
| May 17, 2015 | Menards 200 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Stock Car | Todd Gilliland |
| June 26, 2015 | King of the Wing | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | AVSS Sprint Car | Ryan Litt |
| September 12, 2015 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | AVSS Sprint Car | Jimmy McCune | |
| September 12, 2015 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | MSA Supermodified | A.J. Lesiecki | |
| May 22, 2016 | Menards 200 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Stock Car | Myatt Snider |
| June 10, 2016 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | MSA Supermodified | Dave McKnight | |
| May 21, 2017 | Menards 200 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Stock Car | Harrison Burton |
| June 16, 2017 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | MSA Supermodified | A.J. Lesiecki | |
| May 20, 2018 | Menards 200 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Stock Car | Zane Smith |
| May 19, 2019 | Sioux Chief PowerPEX 200 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Stock Car | Chandler Smith |
| June 13, 2020 | Herr's Potato Chips 200 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA East Series | Ty Gibbs |
| July 31, 2020 | Menards.com 200 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Stock Car | Sam Mayer |
| August 1, 2020 | Menards 200 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Stock Car | Sam Mayer |
| September 12, 2020 | Royal Truck & Trailer 200 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Stock Car/East Series | Sam Mayer |
| May 22, 2021 | Herr's Potato Chips 200 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Stock Car | Ty Gibbs |
| October 8, 2022 | Shore Lunch 200 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Stock Car | Sammy Smith |
| October 7, 2023 | Shore Lunch 200 | Toledo Speedway, Toledo, OH | ARCA Stock Car | William Sawalich |